Advanced Structural Theory · Ch. 12, pp. 102–104

Tapered Bar Elements

A bar fixed at x = 0 has area A(x) = A0(1 − m x/L) and carries an axial load P at x = L. Compare the exact solution with exact elements, quadratic elements (nodes at 0, h/2, h) and linear elements. Displacements are in units of PL/(EA0) and stresses in P/A0.

The bar and the meshes

Shading shows the exact stress P/A(x), darker where the bar is thinner. Filled dots are element end nodes; open dots are the mid-side nodes of the quadratic elements.

Results

ModelElementsUnknownsu(L)Error in u(L)Energy-norm errorMax stress error

Max stress error is the largest |σh − σ| along the bar divided by the largest exact stress, P/A(L). With exact integration, the energy-norm error is √(1 − uh(L)/u(L)).

Displacement u(x)

Stress and axial force

Convergence

Things to try

  1. Reproduce p. 104. At m = 2/3 with one element each, the linear element gives u(L) = 1.500 (−9.0%) and the quadratic element gives 1.636 (−0.7%). The exact value is 1.648.
  2. Set m = 0. The bar is prismatic, the exact field is linear, and every model is exact.
  3. Look at the sign of the errors. Every element solution is too stiff, so uh(L) ≤ u(L). The assumed fields minimize the total potential energy only within their own family.
  4. Compare at the same number of unknowns. Two linear elements and one quadratic element both have two unknowns. Which is closer?
  5. Switch the stress plot to axial force. The exact N equals P everywhere. The element solutions satisfy equilibrium only at the nodes, so N varies inside each element.
  6. Try the graded mesh with m near 0.9. Short elements at the thin end capture the steep stress there.
  7. Look at the exact element. One element is enough: its shape functions solve the governing equation (p. 103), so it reproduces the exact displacement and stress along the whole bar. Its stiffness uses the log-mean area where the linear element uses the arithmetic mean.

Element stiffness

Linear element
k = (E Ā / h) [1 −1; −1 1]
Ā = (Aa + Ab)/2, the arithmetic mean of the end areas.
Exact element
k = (E Ã / h) [1 −1; −1 1]
à = (Aa − Ab) / ln(Aa/Ab), the log-mean of the end areas. Shape functions N = ln(A/Aa)/ln(Ab/Aa).
Quadratic element
kij = ∫ E A(x) Ni′ Nj′ dx
Lagrange shape functions on nodes 0, h/2, h. One element over the whole bar gives the 3 × 3 matrix on p. 103.